Main Content

Shrewsbury banner-logo
Home » Shrewsbury

Shrewsbury

Shrewsbury

Median Home Prices

$559,900
Lowest
$799,000
Median
$2,175,000
Highest

Median Home Price

Per Square Feet
$334 sq ft
Lowest
$352 sq ft
Median
$459 per sq ft
Highest

Average Home Statistics

In Terms Of
3
No. of beds
2
No. of baths
2,579 sq ft
Square feet
Introduction

Shrewsbury listing house

Consistently recognized as one of the best places to live in New Jersey, Shrewsbury offers the perfect mix of suburban living and small-town charm. The quality of life that Shrewsbury offers its residents is second to none. Residents have access to highly-rated schools, incredible restaurants, and well-maintained parks, just to name a few of the benefits. In Shrewsbury. NJ, you’ll also find friendly faces in a close-knit community and fantastic homes for sale. In short, Shrewsbury has all the makings of a place where you’d want to set up home.

A Brief History

The borough gets its name from the Shrewsbury town in western England, however, Shrewsbury, NJ has its own rich and storied history. In its time, it was heavily involved in the events of the Revolutionary War and the development of the railroad. The borough’s story is closely intertwined with that of Shrewsbury Township.

When the township was established, it covered a large area that made up the Navesink Patent or Monmouth Tract. After Shrewsbury was officially established as a borough on March 22, 1926, as an act of the New Jersey Legislature, it officially broke off from Shrewsbury Township.

Today Shrewsbury is still a relatively small borough having never seen significant industrialization. This has allowed it to not only keep its natural beauty unspoiled but also maintain its wonderful sense of community.

Overview of Shrewsbury, NJ

Climate

Shrewsbury’s generally pleasant weather makes it a great destination to visit all year round. That said, residents enjoy all four seasons, something that enriches the whole living experience with different things to do at different times of the year. Summertime in the borough is warm with some rain. Winter in Shrewsbury, on the other hand, can get very cold and there will often be seasons when residents make the most of the snow.

Getting Around

While Shrewsbury doesn’t have a dedicated public transportation system, it’s easy to travel in and out of Shrewsbury using the efficient bus and train lines of the state. The New Jersey Coast Line (NJCL) is a railway line with a station in Red Bank and Little Silver. The nearest bus stops are located along Route 35 and White Street, Obre Place, and Meadow Drive.

The nearest major airport to Shrewsbury is the Newark Liberty International Airport, which is the largest commercial airport in New Jersey. Newark Airport is less than an hour’s drive via Garden State Parkway. New York City is only an hour away from Shrewsbury.

Cost of Living

Living in Shrewsbury comes at a premium, and is around 14% higher than the national average. It is also around 9% more expensive than most New Jersey cities. This is not surprising as it is one of the most affluent areas of New Jersey. While the cost of living in Shrewsbury is higher, the benefits it offers in terms of its prime location, proximity to major cities and area beaches, and also the high quality of life it provides, make it worth the investment.

Community Culture

Shrewsbury waterfront houses

Shrewsbury has a tight-knit community, where the residents take pride in preserving the borough’s rich history and natural beauty. The community’s dedication to preserving its environmental heritage is shown in initiatives like the Community Garden and the Garden Club. In addition, Shrewsbury is actively working on becoming a green community. In 1970, Shrewsbury established the Environmental Commission to protect its natural resources and promote eco-friendly practices. The commission’s main goal is to put a spotlight on the three R’s: Reduce, Restore, and Recycle. Long before the Green issues became popular, Shrewsbury was looking at ways to preserve the area.

Job Opportunities

While the borough had its roots in agriculture and fishing, it has grown to cover a broader range of industries. From education to technology services, there are plenty of opportunities and there is a need for a wide range of skill sets. Finance, healthcare, and professional services are among the biggest industries here, offering high-paying career opportunities.

Schools

The schools in and around Shrewsbury offer a well-rounded education to their students. From preschool to high school, the students are provided with a supportive learning environment.

Shrewsbury has a very highly-rated public school that serves the community, the Shrewsbury Borough School. The school which caters to students from pre-kindergarten all the way to the eighth grade is recognized for its dedicated faculty, challenging academic programs, and personalized learning environment.

For high school, most Shrewsbury students go to the Red Bank Regional High School in the neighboring town of Red Bank. The renowned public school is known for its distinguished academic program and extensive athletic and co-curricular activities.

Private options include Vincent S Mastro Montessori Academy, Leapfrog Learning Center, and Creative Learning Center.

Homes for Sale in Shrewsbury, NJ

Shrewsbury bungalow house

From luxurious custom estates to charming single-family residences, Shrewsbury offers a wide selection of properties for the discerning buyer. The homes for sale in Shrewsbury, NJ feature a mix of older, historic homes and new construction properties. Regardless of age, you can expect comfort, space, and excellent amenities from these homes. 

Shrewbury’s housing market provides options for individuals and families at every stage of life, from young professionals to retirees. There are townhomes that cater to the low-maintenance lifestyle, single-family residences with expansive floor plans, and luxury estates with upscale amenities.

POPULAR NEIGHBORHOODS

  • Shrewsbury Historic District. Steeped in history, the Shrewsbury Historic District is full of character and charm. Many of the homes within the district were built in the 19th and 20th centuries, featuring stunning Victorian-era styles and other architectural gems. The Shrewsbury Historic District lies within the Historic Four Corners.
  • Heritage Greens. A highly-coveted neighborhood in Shrewsbury, Heritage Greens enjoys the best of both worlds: A serene suburban setting that is conveniently close to amenities, schools, and parks. The residential properties in the neighborhood are predominantly single-family homes with around 3 to 4 bedrooms.
  • The Ivy at Shrewsbury. When it comes to townhouse living, The Ivy at Shrewsbury offers space, luxury, and thoughtful designs. The community offers 3 distinct floor plans across its 61 units, allowing its residents to choose the space that best suits their lifestyle.
  • Enclave at Shrewsbury. One of the best active adult communities in the borough is the Enclave at Shrewsbury. There are around 66 luxurious single-family homes in this neighborhood, with each one offering spacious living and a low-maintenance lifestyle. The Enclave at Shrewsbury also has top amenities, including a private clubhouse, a putting green, and a walking and biking trail.
  • Paddington Farm. Built in the late 1980s, Paddington Farm is an established community that offers Ranch and Colonial-style single-family homes. The majority of these homes have generous lot sizes and expansive square footage, giving residents plenty of indoor and outdoor space. Unfortunately, unlike the name suggests, you’re not likely to run into any friendly bears from Peru.
Living in Shrewsbury, NJ

Shrewsbury offers plenty of opportunities for outdoor recreation in and around the borough.

The Esther-Hymer Nature Preserve is a scenic nature trail in Shrewsbury that’s just a quarter-mile long. The trail is dedicated to Esther W. Hymer, a peerless advocate for women’s rights. The trail is marked by a large wooden plaque. Another great outdoor area in Shrewsbury is Sickles Park. This welcoming green space is favored by residents and visitors of all ages for its playgrounds, sports fields, and picnic areas.

When you live in Shrewsbury, you’re never far from the water. With Shrewsbury’s convenient location near the Shrewsbury and Navesink Rivers, opportunities for boating, fishing, and relaxing by the water are just a short drive away. Victory Park, which is located in Rumson, is less than 15 minutes away from Shrewsbury. This magnificent park is a waterfront oasis complete with playgrounds, tennis courts, basketball courts, and an amazing view of the Navesink River.

If it’s the ocean you’re after, the Seven Presidents Oceanfront Park in Long Branch is a go-to destination for the sun, sand, and surf. Beachgoers are more than welcome to take a dip in the ocean, catch some waves, or play a game of beach volleyball. Also, many residents of Shrewsbury decide to join one of the numerous private beach clubs in Sea Bright, just a 15 minute drive from town.

Other Popular Attractions and Destinations

The Shrewsbury Historic District is a well-preserved landmark in the borough. Listed on the National Register of Historic Places, this charming area along Broad Street and Sycamore Street is filled with gorgeous Victorian-era homes, local shops, and picturesque gardens. Many of the historic buildings here have been repurposed, and are now occupied by restaurants, shops, and offices.

Also located in the Shrewsbury Historic District is the Allen House. Constructed in 1710, the house was named after its original owner Judah Allen, and has significant historical importance. The Allen House was a bustling tavern and an important social hub during its time. Touring the Allen House is only allowed from May to September.

Close to Shrewsbury, you’ll find a wealth of historical attractions like the Eatontown Historical Museum and the Township of Ocean Historical Museum. The Eatontown Historical Museum in Eatontown, which is open on the first Sunday of each Month, showcases the town’s rich history and heritage through photographs, artifacts, and interactive exhibits. South of Shrewsbury, in Ocean Township, the Ocean Historical Museum provides a unique look at the town’s history and how it developed.

Shopping

When it comes to shopping, Shrewsbury has options for everyone.

The Grove at Shrewsbury stands out as a premier shopping destination in the borough. As New Jersey’s first lifestyle center, the open-air mall features a curated collection of upscale retailers, local boutiques, and dining options. Whether you’re looking for the latest trends or on the hunt for a unique gift, you’ll find what you’re looking for at The Grove at Shrewsbury.

woman outdoor shopping

Shrewsbury is also home to retail shops like Jolie by the Sea Boutique, Oh Honey Boutique, and Chelsea. These local boutiques offer a curated selection of fashion-forward clothing, accessories, and other unique finds.

For eclectic home decor and furnishings, World Market has a location right in Shrewsbury. From wall art to outdoor furniture, you’ll find a ton of items that add color and style to your home.

Dining

Shrewsbury’s dining scene is full of culinary experiences. From cozy cafes to upscale eateries, Shrewsbury and its neighboring towns have something to satisfy every palate.

Corbo & Sons Osteria offers an authentic Italian dining experience right here in Shrewsbury. The restaurant, which was started by chef and owner Richard Corbo, brings the tradition of Italian osteria dining to life. Corbo & Sons Osteria’s menu is divided into appetizers, pastas, and entrees.

Located in the heart of Shrewsbury, The Baker’s Grove is not your average bakery. This artisan bakeshop makes its own pastries, cookies, desserts, and savory items from scratch. With the amount of care and attention put into making these culinary delights, you can’t go wrong with a single item from their menu.

Other notable restaurants in Shrewsbury include Albariño Tapas & Wine Bar, djeet, and Bayroot Lebanese Restaurant.

Local Events

  • The Annual Shrewsbury 5k Classic – More than just a race, this annual event brings together the entire Shrewsbury community in support of the Foundation for Shrewsbury Education mission. Students, teachers, and Shrewsbury residents of all ages take part in the Annual Shrewsbury 5k Classic.
  • Easter Egg Hunt – A beloved tradition in the community, Shrewbury’s annual Easter Egg Hunt is a fun-filled morning for children of all ages. The event also has prizes, ice cream, and music.
  • Monmouth Conservation Foundation’s Holiday Style Luncheon – Typically held at The Shadowbrook at Shrewsbury, one of the most stunning event venues in the region, this annual event includes a luncheon, fashion show, and shopping spree.
Discover The Best Of Shrewsbury, NJ

hand shake agreement

Ready to explore homes for sale in Shrewsbury, NJ? Enlist the expertise of an experienced Realtor like me, Mario Venancio. As the leading real estate agent in Monmouth County for the past 13 years, I can help you navigate the Shrewsbury real estate market and ensure you find the property you’ll be delighted to own.

Let’s get started on your Shrewsbury, NJ home buying journey! Call me at 732.881.4306 or send me an email here.

HP Work With Mario

Work With Mario

If you’ve always dreamed of tranquil suburban living close to the ocean and close enough to the greatest city in the world, New York, Rumson, NJ is for you. Let a local real estate expert like Mario Venancio help you fulfill your real estate goals. Contact Mario at 732.881.4306 or send him a message here.

Skip to content